The office of vice president—the second-highest position in the executive branch, and first in the constitutional line of succession—might seem like a good launching pad for a politician with aspirations of attaining the nation’s highest office. But relatively few vice presidents—just 15 of the 49 who served between 1789 and 2021—became president, and eight of those did it by taking over after the death of a president, while another, Gerald R. Ford, rose to the office when his predecessor, Richard M. Nixon, resigned. Only six vice presidents managed to get elected president on their own.
“Vice presidents are pretty successful at gaining their party’s nomination for president,” says John McGlennon, a professor at William & Mary university in Virginia, where he specializes in American politics. “But they’re less successful at actually winning elections.”
One prominent example is Hubert Humphrey, who served as Lyndon B. Johnson’s vice president and was chosen as the Democratic nominee at the 1968 Democratic Convention, but then lost the presidential election that fall. Other vice presidents who managed to win Democratic nomination—Walter Mondale, VP under Jimmy Carter, and Al Gore, VP under Bill Clinton—also failed in 1984 and 2000, respectively (although Gore managed to win the popular vote).
“Sometimes voters are just ready to move on,” McGlennon says.
The job also creates certain hindrances to future aspirations. “The nature of being vice president is to stay in the background,” explains University of Richmond political science professor Christopher Miller. “It’s hard to pivot from that to taking the spotlight and convincing people you deserve it.”
Which VPs stand the best chance of being elected? Possibly, the ones who wait to run, so they can position themselves as challengers rather than incumbents.
“If you look at modern history, two of three VPs who became president did so after a gap between their vice presidency and presidency: Nixon and Biden,” says Gayle Alberda, an associate professor of politics at Fairfield University.
Here are American vice presidents who became president—despite the odds.