John Adams arrived in France in 1778 to replace Silas Deane, an American ambassador dismissed for fraud. Adams was a brilliant writer and political philosopher, but his blunt, straight-talking demeanor clashed with French courtly manners. Instead of easing Franklin’s load in Paris, Adams’s very presence became an obstacle.
“The two men got off on the wrong foot and remained there,” says Schiff. “It didn’t help that Adams failed to ingratiate himself at Court and resented Franklin’s tremendous celebrity.”
In letters home, Adams complained bitterly about Franklin—everything from the older statesman’s inferior French to the way the famous inventor was greeted like “an opera girl” everywhere he went.
As foreign ambassadors, Adams and Franklin couldn’t have been more different in style and personality. Adams refused to acknowledge America’s indebtedness to France and approached Versailles with urgent ultimatums for more supplies and military support. In contrast, Franklin was ingratiating and patient—always careful to make requests of America’s benefactors, not demands.
By the end of the war, Adams and Franklin still disliked each other immensely, but they were able to see past their differences long enough to successfully negotiate a peace treaty with Britain that recognized America’s independence. Through it all, Adams’s opinion of Franklin never improved.
“If I was in Congress, and this gentleman and the marble Mercury in the garden at Versailles were in nomination for an embassy, I would not hesitate to give my vote for the statue,” Adams wrote a colleague in 1783, “upon the principle that it would do no harm.”
Franklin's Homecoming
America could not have won the Revolutionary War without France. Schiff estimates the total value of French material and manpower at roughly $20 billion in today’s money. It was enough to bankrupt the government of Louis XVI, one of the aggravating factors that led to the French Revolution.
“When the British surrendered at Yorktown they did so to forces that were nearly equal parts French and American,” says Schiff, “all fed, clothed and paid by France, and protected by a French navy.”
Benjamin Franklin was the reason why France opened its coffers so wide to the unproven Americans. To put it simply, the French liked him and trusted him.
“Nothing could have been more critical to our Revolution than that affection,” says Schiff. “Every other American envoy who approached Versailles bungled along the way. Franklin was inventing the foreign service out of whole cloth. And he was, as we know from so many other realms, a brilliant inventor.”
Franklin was almost 80 when he crossed the Atlantic a final time and returned to a Philadelphia he hardly recognized. America had changed immensely in the nine years he was laboring abroad, and that included a new generation of politicians. Franklin had hoped to receive some compensation for his difficult mission—as others had—but Congress didn’t want to dwell on the debt America owed to France.
“The French mission had been, hands down, the most taxing assignment of Franklin’s life,” says Schiff. “Congress never offered a settling of accounts, a reward, or so much as a single syllable of thanks.”