Frank Herbert: An Early Environmentalist
Dune made a big impact on the environmental movement, which Herbert largely embraced. “I refuse to be put in the position of telling my grandchildren, ‘Sorry, there’s no more world for you. We used it up,’” Herbert said at the first Earth Day in 1970.
Herbert also helped organize environmental groups at the University of Washington, where he taught. And he was an early proponent of renewable energy, installing his own solar collector and windmill and speaking out against internal combustion engines.
Many environmentalists interpreted Dune as a critique of the oil industry, with Herbert’s friend Willis E. McNelly writing that the empire’s reliance on spice can “be construed as a thinly veiled allegory of our world’s insatiable appetite for oil and other petroleum products.” Canavan agrees, saying “it’s impossible that [Herbert} wasn’t thinking about oil.”
Deserts of Oregon Inspire Herbert
It wasn’t oil, but rather sand dunes and the science of ecology, that sparked Herbert’s idea in the first place. In 1957, Herbert visited Florence, Oregon, where the U.S. Department of Agriculture was attempting to stabilize the area’s sand dunes—and therefore prevent them from damaging roads and buildings—by planting European beachgrass and other fast-growing foliage. “For Herbert, this was inspirational,” says Veronika Kratz, a literary scholar at Queen’s University in Canada and author of a 2021 essay on Herbert’s ecological thinking.
Herbert planned to write a journalism article on Oregon’s dunes, titled “They Stopped the Moving Sands.” The piece was never finalized, but it prompted Herbert to begin researching dunes, deserts and ecology as a whole. The author later claimed to have read over 200 books as background for Dune and was particularly influenced by the ecologist Paul Sears.
“He used Sears’ language almost directly in certain portions of Dune,” says Katherine Buse, an assistant professor of cinema and media studies at the University of Chicago, who has written about this subject.
Water Scarcity as a Theme
Buse credits Herbert for being among the first writers to contemplate ecological change on a planetary scale—which, as she explains, makes him popular among certain climate scientists—and for showing “how dependent we are on the environment.” In particular, Buse says, he imagines “what extreme water scarcity would do to a society and how it would shape every aspect of that society.”
Herbert dedicated his novel to "dry-land ecologists, wherever they may be," and includes a planetary ecologist who dreams of "greening" Arrakis as one of the novel's characters.
Herbert’s environmentalism, however, had its limitations. According to Kratz, he believed that as long as humans understood the ecological consequences of their actions, they could effectively manage resource extraction. The protagonists of Dune essentially yearn to destroy the desert in favor of agriculture. Today, Kratz argues, “It’s not really a question of how we fix deserts to make it easier to live there, it’s more a question of, ‘why do we want to fix the deserts?’ Arid regions are vibrant and full of life.”
Even the sand dune stabilization project in Oregon, which Herbert found so inspirational, is now viewed negatively by environmentalists. In fact, attempts are currently underway to undo the prior work. By removing European beachgrass and other non-native species, conservationists hope to restore Oregon's coastal dune ecosystem.