Historians routinely rank Franklin Delano Roosevelt as one of the most influential and successful of all the American presidents. But his 12-year period in the White House, from 1933 to 1945, also had its share of controversy.
His record-breaking four terms in office coincided with some of the most significant events in 20th century history, as he steered the country through both the Great Depression and World War II. Facing grave threats to capitalism and democracy, F.D.R. helped preserve both. “The world we live in today is Franklin Roosevelt’s world,” wrote the late historian Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr. in a profile of the 32nd president he penned in 1998.
But like all presidents, F.D.R. courted criticism—both for what he did and what he failed to do. Even his signature New Deal initiative, which helped jump-start the U.S. economy and provide vulnerable Americans with a safety net, drew fire. While supporters hailed it as a visionary new approach to governing, critics contended that it set a dangerous precedent for expanding the federal government’s role in the economy and society.
Scholars and analysts continue to bicker over his legacy, with the most persistent criticism concentrated in a few key areas.