Alexander Butterfield
HIS ROLE: As deputy White House chief of staff to President Nixon from 1969 to 1973, Butterfield controlled the secret taping system Nixon had installed in the Oval Office. He revealed the existence of the tapes when he was questioned by the Senate Watergate Committee, effectively sealing Nixon’s fate.
THE UPSHOT: Ironically, Butterfield liked Nixon—but he did not want to lie to investigators. “I was facing a true dilemma: I wanted very much to respect Nixon’s wishes and at the same time to be cooperative and forthright with the congressional investigators,” he later said. “The wording of their questions meant everything to me. And when Don Sanders, the deputy minority counsel…asked the $64,000 question, clearly and directly, I felt I had no choice but to respond in like manner.” With Nixon’s resignation, Butterfield was also dismissed from his post as administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration—to which he’d been appointed by the president.
POST-SCANDAL: Butterfield had trouble finding work for two years following Watergate, but eventually found a job as chief operating officer at an air-transport company, then ran a financial holdings company and a consulting company in California. In 2015, he re-entered the spotlight as the subject of a book by Bob Woodward, titled The Last of the President’s Men. In it, Butterfield describes his reaction as he watched Nixon’s farewell address: “I could not believe that people were crying in that room… It was sad, yes. But justice had prevailed. Inside I was cheering.”
THE SPECIAL PROSECUTOR
Archibald Cox
HIS ROLE: Assigned in May of 1973 as special prosecutor to investigate the Watergate scandal, Archibald Cox was fired from his post by President Nixon just five months later in what became known as the “Saturday Night Massacre”—a White House shake-up that led to the resignation of two other Justice Department staffers. Cox was fired after insisting President Nixon give him unrestricted access to tapes of conversations leading up to the break-in at the Democratic National Committee Headquarters.
THE UPSHOT: Following his dismissal, Cox said in a statement: "Whether ours shall continue to be a government of laws and not of men is now for Congress and ultimately the American people." Nixon’s firing of Cox fueled the Watergate investigation, leading to a public backlash against Nixon and Congressional resolutions calling for his impeachment.
POST-SCANDAL: After leaving Washington, Cox—who had previously served as solicitor general—taught constitutional law at his alma mater, Harvard Law School. He also worked on the legal team of Common Cause, an advocacy group that lobbies for campaign finance reform. Though he published several books on labor and constitutional law, he did not write about Watergate. But sometime after the scandal, he reportedly stated: “one of the important lessons of Watergate was that unless the government trusts the people and conducts itself in an honorable fashion, then the people won’t trust the government.” He died in 2004.
THE AXE MAN
Robert Bork
HIS ROLE: Bork, a conservative judge, solicitor general and acting attorney general in the Nixon administration, carried out President Nixon’s orders to fire special counsel Archibald Cox, who had subpoenaed conversations taped in the Oval Office. Cox’s dismissal, on Oct. 1973, became known as the “Saturday Night Massacre.”
THE UPSHOT: Despite Bork’s firing of Cox, the Supreme Court eventually ordered Nixon to turn over the tapes.
POST-SCANDAL: In addition to his involvement in Watergate, Bork is also remembered for his failed Supreme Court nomination in 1987, when he was rejected by the U.S. Senate for his conservative policies. So significant was the failed nomination that, “my name became a verb,” (meaning to attack or defeat a candidate for public office) Bork told CNN years later. “And I regard that as one form of immortality.” He went on to serve as a fellow in conservative think tanks and as an advisor to Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign. In his 1996 book, Slouching Towards Gomorrah, Bork criticizes American society and modern liberalism in particular, writing that “decline runs across our entire culture'' and ''the rot is spreading.'' In later years, he married a former Catholic nun and converted to Catholicism. He died in 2012.
THE WHISTLEBLOWER
Mark Felt
HIS ROLE: Known for decades only as “Deep Throat,” the mysterious government source who helped Washington Post reporters Carl Bernstein and Bob Woodward untangle the Watergate conspiracy, Mark Felt revealed his identity in 2005. A senior FBI official during the Watergate years, Mark Felt met from time to time with Woodward—always in deserted parking garages, and always taking extreme precautions to ensure they had not been followed—providing clues that guided the journalist’s reporting. The Nixon White House was “underhanded and unknowable,” he once told Woodward.
THE UPSHOT: With the 1974 release of Woodward and Bernstein’s book about Watergate, All the President’s Men, followed by the movie by the same name, Felt became the most famous anonymous source in journalism. But he was unhappy with the nickname he earned in the Washington Post newsroom, a combination of “deep background” and the titled of a pornographic film released in 1972.
POST-SCANDAL: Though many guessed that Felt was Deep Throat, he repeatedly denied the speculations, including in his 1979 memoir, The FBI Pyramid, in which he contrasted his time under J. Edgar Hoover, whom he revered, with his service under Nixon, whom he disliked. He revealed himself as the Watergate source in a 2005 Vanity Fair article which led to a memoir published a year later, titled A G-Man's Life: The FBI, Being 'Deep Throat’ and the Struggle for Honor in Washington. In the book, Felt writes, "People will debate for a long time whether I did the right thing by helping Woodward… The bottom line is that we did get the whole truth out, and isn't that what the FBI is supposed to do?" He died in 2008, at the age of 95.
THE SENATORS
Sam Ervin
HIS ROLE: As chairman of the Senate Watergate committee that investigated the affair in televised hearings, Ervin became a national hero for serving as a moral compass. The purpose of the hearings, he said at the outset, was to "probe into assertions that the very system has been subverted." The hearings showcased Ervin’s folksy demeanor and direct speech. When criticized for being too harsh on the witnesses, he countered, "I'm just an old country lawyer, and I don't know the finer ways to do it. I just have to do it my way."
THE UPSHOT: More than a year after the hearings began, Nixon became the first U.S. president to resign from office. Ervin retired four months later.
POST-SCANDAL: After Watergate, Ervin returned to his hometown, Morgantown, N.C., where he wrote three books and occasionally appeared in television ads for American Express. As he wrote in The Whole Truth: The Watergate Conspiracy, published in 1980, "Nixon's memoirs insinuate that he was driven from the presidency by a hostile press and vindictive partisans, and not by his own misdeeds”—a statement Ervin said is "totally incompatible" with the facts. All his books, including the subsequent Humor of a Country Lawyer and Preserving the Constitution: The Autobiography of Sen. Sam Ervin, were first drafted in pencil on yellow legal pads. Ervin died in 1988.
Howard Baker
HIS ROLE: A Republican senator from Tennessee, Baker was vice chairman of the Senate Watergate committee that investigated the scandal, and is famously remembered for asking former White House counsel John Dean on June 29, 1973: “What did the President know, and when did he know it?”
THE UPSHOT: Though Baker’s initial goal was to prove the accusations against Nixon were unfounded, testimony he heard and evidence he reviewed during the hearings changed his views. As he told The Associated Press, “it began to dawn on me that there was more to it than I thought, and more to it than I liked.”
POST-SCANDAL: Baker, who unsuccessfully ran for the Republican presidential nomination in 1980, continued to serve in the U.S. Senate until 1985, when he retired to practice law. He returned to Washington two years later to serve as Ronald Reagan’s White House chief of staff and later served as ambassador to Japan under President George W. Bush. Baker particularly took pride in his skill as an “eloquent listener,” saying, "There is a difference between hearing and understanding what people say. You don't have to agree, but you have to hear what they've got to say. And if you do, the chances are much better you'll be able to translate that into a useful position and even useful leadership." He died in 2014.
THE JOURNALISTS